The Quest for the Perfect Oatmeal Cookie Continues

I hope you’re doing well during these crazy times. Since I last wrote, I recovered from Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever and the 2020 election. Both left me exhausted and depleted.

We now have some semblance of closure, the assembly of a reasonably moderate cabinet under a new president-elect, and my white blood cell count is back to normal. Eating all that kale over the past year has done more than help me lose 50 pounds; it’s helped me rebound very quickly from what could have been a long-term illness. I am gateful my doctor encouraged me to adopt the nutritarian diet developed by Dr. Joel Fuhrman.

So, to celebrate, what do I do? Enjoy a berry kale smoothie?

No. I continue my quest for the perfect oatmeal cookie, a.k.a. a cookie like the one my German grandma made so long ago.

Spicy German Oatmeal Cookie or Chock-A-Block?

As some long-time readers of my work know, I’m obsessed with finding the perfect oatmeal cookie recipe. Not just any recipe will do. It must recreate the cookies that my German grandmother (who never wrote down her recipes) made sometime around 1972 when I remember clutching a thick, sweet, spicy cookie in my grubby little hands as I played with my brothers’ train set in the basement.

It was a winter day sometime around 1972 or 1973. I place the date around then because my brothers were still playing with my dad’s old model rail road set. They had set it up in the basement play room. It had huge cars marked “Long Island Rail Road” on the side. When the big transformer box lit up and the cars began to shoot around the track, a light inside the passenger cars illuminated the silhouettes of men in fedoras reading newspapers and ladies in elegant hats peering out of the windows of the train. My imagination leaped at the little silhouettes. I was one with them, peering out at the blurry countryside as the train whisked me to Manhattan.

My dad came home from a trip to his mother’s house and called down to the basement, “Grandma sent sinkers!” My dad nicknamed the German drop doughnuts “sinkas” or “sinkers” because he joked that they were so heavy they sank to the bottom of your stomach.

In reality, sinkas were probably faschnacht, German drop doughnuts. These friend dough balls are very similar to the Italian zeppolis (zeppole) that you can buy at street fairs or on Long Island at pizzerias along with your Coke and a slice.

Now, much as I love baking…I think my husband would have a fit if I friend up 277 calorie dough balls, no matter how delicious and nostalgic they made me.

But I can get away with oatmeal cookies. Oatmeal, raisins, walnuts, they’re all nutritious foods. Of course, they’re mixed with heaps of butter or shortening, brown and white sugar, and eggs, but….oatmeal is healthy, right?

So I turn to the cookies I recall from that day in 1972: my grandmother’s oatmeal cookies.

Grandma’s German Oatmeal Cookies or What Was That Spice?

Along with the sinkers (faschnacht) my grandmother sent home a plate of oatmeal cookies. Giant, thick cookies packed with stuff: nuts, raisins, chocolate chips.

And a heavenly spice I have yet been able to duplicate.

The cookies were thick and solid, not the soft, squishy things you get when you make the recipe on the back of the oatmeal canister. I’m sure they kept for a long time, too, in Grandma’s ever-present cookie jar.

As the quarantine continued and summer turned into fall, I decided to pull out my mixer and continue my question to find a version of my grandmother’s oatmeal cookie recipe.

Dorie Greenspan’s Chock-A-Block Cookies

The logical thing to do when trying to recreate an old-fashioned German oatmeal cookie recipe would be to search online for recipes, right? Of course, but who said I’m logical?

I turned to my cookbook collection first: Fannie Farmer, Better Home and Gardens, Betty Crocker, and Dorie Greenspan’s book, Baking: From my home to yours.

My husband bought me this book many years ago when I first took up cooking as a hobby. I haven’t used it much over the years. Although the recipes looked good, I was intimidated by the techniques and special ingredients needed. It wasn’t until this year that I picked up the book again seeking new oatmeal cookie recipes and found a treasury of interesting recipes to try.

These recipes are not for the diet conscious. Sticks of unsalted butter, several eggs, and lots of sugar ensure that each cookie is a calorie bomb of delightful sweetness and artery-clogging cholesterol. But they taste heavenly and the ChockABlock cookies recipe on page 86 of the book came the closest to my grandmother’s recipe as I’ve ever baked.

The secret? Molasses.

I had only blackstrap molasses on hand, and the recipe specifically said NOT to use blackstrap molasses, but in the middle of a pandemic it’s not smart to hop into the car and head out to the store for a spontaneous additional grocery store trip. Catching COVID-19 isn’t worth baking the perfect cookie no matter how much I would love to find the right medley of flavors to recreate that long-ago childhood memory.

So I used blackstrap molasses, added walnuts, raisins, and chocolate chips, and….oh, so close. So very, very close to grandma’s cookies!

The molasses added the spiciness that traditional oatmeal cookie recipes lacked, but still, there was something missing. I suspect it’s cloves – my grandmother loved to add cloves to her baking and I love cloves, too – but it could have been allspice.

ACK! Will I ever find the perfect recipe?

I am now doing the logical thing – searching online for German oatmeal cookie recipes. Perhaps it is the spice that is missing. Or perhaps traditional molasses, not blackstrap, would give the cookies the right spicy-sweet blend.

Or perhaps it’s my grandma who is missing, or me missing her bone-crushing hugs. Maybe grandma’s love was, all along, the secret ingredient to her cookies.

 

 

 

The Best Present of All – Presence

Our breath spangled the frosty December evening as we waved goodbye. My dog, Zeke, dropped, exhausted, to his mat in the living room to dream of chasing tennis balls and his best friend, our neighbors’ boxer dog, Cinder. We’d spent a good two hours watching the dogs zoom like maniacs across the lawn chasing balls and each other. The men wandered to the back for target practice while my neighbor and I leaned on the deck rail, petting Zeke and sharing stories about horses we had known and loved.

It was a perfect Sunday afternoon.


Sundays were once like this, a day of presence, first with God in church, then with family for dinner, then with family and friends for visits or fun. Presence. I think a lot about presence the days especially as social media becomes ubiquitous and most of our interactions with others occur through the computer screen.

My grandmother lived with us and she was one of seven children, so every Sunday one of my aunts or great-aunts or uncles would visit. Visiting hours were typically two or three o’clock; if family did not visit, we piled into my dad’s 1962 blue Ford with the black hood, replaced after a car accident and never repainted, and we’d rumble to the duck pond to feed the ducks or to the playground to swing and slide and play in the fresh air.

Sometimes, if we were very lucky, there would by Jiffy Pop popcorn on the stove and a fire in the “real” fireplace in the living room. Sometimes there would be movies on television or Wild Kingdom or Disney’s Magic Kingdom and soup and sandwiches and more laughter and fun.

But always, presence.

We were fully present with one another. In those days, there were no screens other than the television screen. And even though we lived in metro New York City, there were 8 channels on the television set, and Channel 21 was iffy unless the rabbit-ear antenna was adjusted just right. My mother had no hesitation ordering the television shut off when company came, either, and it stayed silent. The soundtrack of those Sunday afternoons was the laughter from my grandmother and her brothers and sisters as they shared stories and caught up on the gossip from their huge extended family.


Stories. Presence. We have lost the art of visiting and we are rapidly as a society losing the art of being present with one another.

This Christmas season, give the gift that only you can give. Give the gift of presence. Be wholly, fully present. Keep your cellphone in your pocket. Turn off the television and the radio and the music and the internet. Tell stories. Share time together. Play a game. Play with your dogs. Organize hot cocoa and cookies and skating parties and snowman building fun and tree decorating parties and tell stories.

It is the gift everyone will cherish long after the holidays are over.

The Inspiration Behind I SEE YOU

cover of I See You by Jeanne Grunert

Novelists draw from many sources for their inspiration. I draw from my childhood growing up on Long Island, New York. The Dalinger Estate, White Oak Hall, features prominently throughout I SEE YOU my new novel. I draw from three estates on Long Island to create the unique setting for much of the mystery in I SEE YOU.

Old Westbury Gardens

Old Westbury Gardens includes both Westbury House and the gardens designed by the same architect who designed the house. It is truly a gem of Long Island. It was donated by the Phipps family who built the home to the county in the late 1950s and was preserved intact, including furnishings, making it a true treasure.

When I was in junior high school, my older sister completed an internship in the gardens there as part of her biology major in college. I would accompany her to the gardens and have free run while she worked. I spent many hours exploring every nook and cranny of the old estate. On days when the house was open for tours, I loved seeing the interior of the mansion. My favorite room was the music room, a ballroom where concerts and dances were held. I transformed this room, with a bit of poetic license, into the ballroom in the fictional White Oak Hall.

Learn more: Old Westbury Gardens

Oheka Castle

Oheka Castle can be seen for miles around from the North Shore of Long Island. Long Island is mostly flat thanks to glacial action but Otto Herman Khan, the wealthy man who built the enormous estate, actually had soil piled up so that his castle could be seen for miles around.

In 1994, when I was working for one of the prestigious garden centers on the North Shore, we received a call from the new owners of Oheka Castle. We met with them on the grounds and I saw the building under refurbishment. The entire building had been sadly neglected, as had the gardens. After Khan sold the building, it went through a series of changes, including time spent as a military prep school, and the new owners were restoring it to its original 1920s splendor.

I’m happy to say that the castle is now restored and open for events. It’s a hotel, event center, and more. And it’s gorgeous! The library was restored when I saw it in the 1990s and that’s the library I imagined when I wrote about Andrew Dalinger’s library in I SEE YOU.

Learn more: Oheka Castle

Target Rock National Wildlife Refuge (the former Ebsterstadt Estate)

By far the biggest influence on the imaginary White Oak Hall, however, is what is known today as Target Rock National Wildlife Refuge. My husband took me there for long walks while we were dating; we had many lovely picnics on its pebbled beach. It was a quiet, seldom-visited sanctuary in the busy, crowded urban area we lived.

Target Rock itself is a gigantic boulder that during high tide sits out in the bay. During the American Revolution, the British used it for target practice. At low tide, you can walk out and climb to the top.

The estate was once the home of Ferdinand Eberstadt. He was a wealthy lawyer, a diplomat, and a government employee who worked with the CIA and FBI. Eberstadt’s estate consisted of a Georgian manor house and 80 acres of prime land in Lloyd Harbor including beachfront property. The gardens and home were donated to the National Park Service and turned to the Department of the Interior as a wildlife sanctuary. It was this act in 1969 that ended up stopping Shoreham Nuclear Power Plant from being constructed; the danger to migrating wildlife protected on the land helped stop the plant from being built. (Which, as a Long Islander, I can tell you was a relief. You cannot get off the island if an emergency happens. It’s too congested and there are too few bridges and tunnels. We dreaded Shoreham).

When I first visited Target Rock, the mansion was still standing. It was a gloomy old structure with tattered curtains and shades from its days as a headquarters for the Park Service. I’d peer through the dusty windows hoping to see some of its former grandeur, but aside from the old radiators and some interesting woodwork, it wasn’t much to see.

The gardens were sadly neglected too but in the spring you could see just rows and rows of rhododendrons and laurels lining the pathways. The best part of the gardens is the freshwater pond. As in I SEE YOU the pond lies just a few yards from the ocean. There is now a bird-watching blind constructed on its banks and I loved to sit there and observe the great white heron fish. My walks at Target Rock were my Sunday morning “church” in the days before I returned to my Catholic faith. I’d pray, nature watch, and pray some more.

Learn more about Target Rock.

But What About the Ghost?

Yes, I SEE YOU is a ghost story. None of the places mentioned above are said to be haunted. The haunted mansion on Long Island is the old Woolworth mansion. I’ve never been to the estate and it was privately owned when I lived near its location. However, a good friend who was a professional photographer gained permission to photograph the estate.

She took a picture…and saw a mysterious figure in the window.

Of the empty mansion.

I saw the picture. It was many years ago, but the ghostly image in the window still gives me the shivers. At the time the image was taken, computer graphics were in their infancy and she didn’t have a computer, so it wasn’t a photoshopped image. It just was…creepy.

The mansion itself is said to be haunted by Woolworth’s daughter and I’ve heard all sorts of stories about rapping sounds on the pipes and odd shadows. It was enough to get my imagination primed for the ghostly happenings in I SEE YOU.

Did you miss the first book? It’s still available!

The Gifts that He Gives

My husband held the bird’s nest out to me. “Feel the inside.”

I reached out and touched the tiny nest gingerly. “It’s soft.”

“The inside is lined in some soft moss,” he said. “And the outside is woven of coarse pine needles.”

I marveled at the perfect construction of the little bird’s nest. We’d watched the sparrows build their nest among the boughs of the nectarine tree in the orchard. Our seven cats miraculously ignored the plain little birds flitting back and forth to the low-hanging branch as the sparrows wove the sturdy little nest.

The mother sparrow snuggled tightly against her two little eggs while papa kept an eye out for intruders. They allowed us to water the nectarine, flying away but always returning to the swaying boughs where their eggs waited.

One day, we saw eggshells underneath the tree – little blue eggshells the color of a spring sky. We kept a safe distance, forgoing watering the transplanted trees for the privacy of a young family experiencing the joys of parenthood.

A few days ago, my husband realized that the nest was empty. The birds were gone. Just like that, the two had fledged, and the parents flew off to wherever birds go when they know a job is well done.

Wind displaced the nest, flinging it to the earth below where the eggshell clues had fallen. We were able to examine the nest at leisure. We studied the neatly woven pine needles, the strands of grass used to build up the sides to prevent the eggs from rolling out.

Mostly, we marveled at the ingenious way the mother bird had softened the nest just for her little ones.

In Sunday’s gospel reading (Luke 11:1-13) we heard the story of Jesus’ disciples asking him to teach them how to pray. And he does by teaching them to address God as “Our Father.”

Not “My father” or “Jesus’ father” – but Our Father, who art in heaven.

Our Father.

Everyone’s father.

Knock, and the door shall be opened unto you.

Ask and ye shall receive.

If a child asks for a fish, a father does not give him a snake.

If he asks for an egg, a father does not give him a scorpion.

 

Twelve years ago, I thought I wanted a black Labrador retriever named Molly. She was at the Prince Edward County Animal Shelter and we longed for a dog. We’d waited until after our move to Virginia to replace Mr. Foxhound, our previous dog, who was not a foxhound at all but a golden retriever mix.

Molly lounged in her kennel during our drive-by while the shelter was closed. I telephoned the animal control officer as quickly as I could. “I’d like to make an appointment to see the Labrador retrievers.”

We made the appointment and on Wednesday, April 30, drove to the shelter.

The Labradors, it turned out, were nuts.

To be fair, they were probably kept in a kennel without any socialization, but they ignored us. Molly was in a kennel with a companion and the two, when let into the play area for our meet and greet, never stopped for an instant. Nor did they greet us or even acknowledge our existence.

We rose and politely excused ourselves, letting the animal control officer know that these dogs wouldn’t do. What we thought we wanted wasn’t right for us. She asked us what we did want; what kind of dog did we think would fit in with our family?

“I have what I think you are looking for,” she said and whisked away to return with a scrawny female German shepherd.

The dog had ticks, long fur (my husband was against a long-coated dog after the Golden retriever mix killed two vacuums struggling to suck up fur embedded in the carpet), and sorrowful eyes. But she smiled at us shyly and extended a paw when asked. She sat, placed her chin on my husband’s knee, and we were smitten.

That dog, Shadow, turned out to be one of the gifts of my life. My constant companion 24/7, she chased bears off the trail for me, threw herself between me and a creepy man who stopped to talk to us on a walk and kept the deer from eating our apple trees.

Oh sure, she had her problems. She may not have been what I wanted, but she was what I needed on a deep, character-changing level. She answered the deepest need of my heart, and our relationship forever changed my life’s priorities.

God the Father gives us what we need, not what we want. I wanted a black Lab named Molly. I needed a long-haired German shepherd dog named Shadow who taught me the meaning of unconditional love, who softened my heart, who made me feel safe and loved.

Photo by Genessa Panainte on Unsplash

Sparrows are such humble, unobtrusive birds. Most people barely notice them. Yet their morning songs often delight my senses, transporting me decades in time to when I was a child, playing in the May morning light in our driveway, digging under the privet hedge, skipping under the clothesline.

The instinct of parents is to protect, give, and nurture their young. To give them good things – an egg, a fish, soft moss inside the swell of a deep nest in the boughs of a nectarine tree.

If something as simple and small as a sparrow knows to give its children good things, then what God gives us must be wonderful indeed. Knowing a gift when we receive it – a shelter dog up for adoption, an overflowing septic tank (another story for another day), the sight of a crimson cardinal on a snowy day – is grace. Embracing it is surrendering to love; to accept that we are loved beyond measure. It is a gift and an awesome, fearful thing, to be loved by this God.

The young sparrows flew away. We see them now, testing their wings, but they return frequently to the boughs of the nectarine tree where a soft nest was prepared for them.

Spiritual Growth Requires Springs of Living Water

Our spiritual growth requires abundant springs of living water. What should we do when the well runs dry?

 

As a transplant myself, I appreciate how hard it is to take root and grow in new soil.

I should have recognized the signs of transplant shock in the redbud tree – and offered some salve, some support as it struggled to take root.

We moved the young sapling in the cool of an early June morning. We watered it for a while, lavishing care and attention on it in its new location.

By July, the leaves turned brown and crispy. They fluttered to the ground.

“It’s dead,” we thought.

We stopped watering it. We debated digging it up, but the heat of a Virginia summer held us back. “In the fall,” we thought, “we’ll dig it up and toss the remains in the woods.”

We forgot about the poor little redbud tree.

Then the rains came. The heavens opened and streams of water gushed from the sky in a torrential thunderstorm that poured forth over an inch and a half of rain in a short cloudburst.

And a leaf appeared.

Now one leaf, but two…then three heart-shaped leaves grew during the following days.

heart shaped leaf redbud tree

Our tree wasn’t dead but alive. It needed drenching showers of cool water on its roots to recover from the pain of being ripped up by its roots, dragged over the earth, and tamped into new ground. It had depleted itself and needed renewal.

I thought of my little tree today as I contemplated an email sent to me from a church friend who heads up one of the most public ministries at church. Not only did she resign from the ministry, but she also indicated she was leaving the church itself. Perhaps it would be temporary. Perhaps for good. She did not know. But she needed time and space to figure out for herself what she believed.

I think my friend is like my little redbud tree. She poured all her energy into the ministry, into leading this group and that group, into being an indispensable part of our little church community. But in the end, all this pouring forth of self left her own spiritual well dry – so dry and barren that in order to save her spiritual life, she felt she had to leave us, the church, for a while to replenish her store of spiritual grace.

We forget that people need to quench their spiritual thirst just as much as my little tree needed to quench its thirst. We need living water to heal our souls. If we are so busy we cannot drink the living water of God, we wither and die. Like my redbud tree, we dry up. We hit the spiritual dryness the saints spoke about. We fail to produce fruit.

I pray daily for my friend that she returns to the church. She’s poured out her own spirit to everyone else, and the well has gone dry, and she needs a good, quenching spiritual rain to put down fresh roots and push forth new leaves that look up towards heaven.

Pray for her, will you?


3 d i see youMy new book, I See You – Book 2 of The Majek Family Mysteries, will be released in Fall 2019. Read Book 1, I Believe You, in paperback or Kindle. Buy your copy on Amazon.com

 

 

Miracles Are All Around Us

Miracles are all around us if we just slow down enough to stop, look, and listen. Most of us are rushing so much we’re trapped in our own thoughts. We barely get out of our own way long enough to recognize something beautiful. To recognize a God-moment in our lives takes practice but once you begin recognizing all the little miracle moments, you realize that God is as close as your heart.

This morning, my God breeze – a little whisper from God – came in the form of a bird.

My husband and I live on a 17-acre farm. We love to observe the wildlife around us. I’ve noticed a lot of activity from a male and female cardinal who seemed to be flying back and forth to a tall pine tree behind the meditation bench in the garden. Then, a few weeks ago, we began hearing the chirping – baby cheeps, little pips, the sound of new life.

But I couldn’t find the nest! Try as I might, I could not see the nest – not from the garden, not from my office windows which face the garden, not with binoculars. Mama Cardinal had hidden her nest quite well. Smart lady, especially when she and her mate chose a pine tree in a yard inhabited by six cats.

Weeks passed and I wondered how my cardinal friends fared. I almost didn’t go out to work in the vegetable garden this morning. My choices were to work on my novel, head out to the trail to do a training walk for the 5K I plan to do in September, or work in the vegetable garden.

“God, what should I do?” I prayed.

My spirit said, garden, so I donned my gardening clothes and headed out. I was picking peas when a sharp, insistent chirp made me look up.

Startled, I focused on not one, but four birds, all in a row on a branch in the peach tree. Juvenile cardinals – four of them, each one taking a turn to send me a cheery farewell before they fluttered, as if with one mind, up into the air, stumbling a bit and uncertain on their wings, each soaring to a different corner of the yard.

I was stunned. I knew instantly that it wasn’t just coincidence. These four had to be the offspring raised in the pine tree just a few hundred feet away. I have seen baby birds on their first day of flight and the nestlings tend to cluster like this on boughs and branches, sticking together until they gain strength and confidence in their wings.

And here they were…the four of them I had listened to for several weeks, chirping “Goodbye.”

You may say it is a coincidence, and that’s your prerogative. As for me, I choose to believe that God sends me little signs every once in a while to remind me of his love, and his creation, and its beauty, so I can remember the good in the world.

(c) Copyright: steve_byland / Licensed from DepositPhotos.com

error: Content is protected !!